Every year, college football produces one weekend that completely destroys the illusion that anybody knows what they’re talking about.
Poll voters spend six weeks carefully constructing a hierarchy. Television networks happily market heavyweight contenders. Analysts publish playoff projections with all the confidence of people reading tomorrow’s newspaper. Podcasts hosts write articles extoling the virtues of this team or that.
Then a Saturday like Week 7 arrives and sets the whole thing on fire.
Five AP Top-10 teams lost. Four of them were genuine upsets. By the end of Saturday night, the sport had produced the first regular season since 1936 in which five of the nation’s top seven teams were beaten on the same day!!
The rankings didn’t just change. They imploded.
No. 1 Georgia 24, Auburn 27

The biggest shock of the season?
For most of the afternoon, it looked as though Georgia would survive another test.
The Bulldogs raced out to a 14-0 lead, the crowd settled in, and an unranked Auburn side appeared destined to become another footnote in a championship campaign.
Instead, it became part of college football history.
The Tigers responded with 24 consecutive points, turning confidence into anxiety inside Sanford Stadium. When Gunner Stockton’s late turnover handed Auburn one final opportunity, the visitors seized it. A 34-yard field goal from Alex McPherson as time expired gave Auburn a stunning 27-24 victory and ended Georgia’s 93-game home winning streak against unranked opponents.
The final whistle produced the kind of silence usually associated with libraries and funerals.
Georgia spent the first six weeks looking like the best team in America.
For one Saturday, they looked human.
No. 2 Notre Dame 24, BYU 28

Provo becomes the centre of the college football world
Later that evening, another unbeaten giant fell.
Notre Dame arrived in Provo carrying a 16-game winning streak and legitimate national title ambitions. They left with a 1 in the Loss column, a bruised playoff CV and a fanbase demanding to know where the official’s flags were being kept.
BYU refused to be intimidated by rankings or reputation. After Notre Dame fought back to take the lead, quarterback Bear Bachmeier engineered a decisive late drive, finding tight end Walker Lyons for the go-ahead touchdown with less than two minutes remaining.
Then came the ending that was pure controversy.
Notre Dame’s final possession reached the shadow of the goal line before ending on a pass that fell incomplete near the goal line. Many Irish fans immediately argued that a pass interference flag should have been thrown. Officials disagreed. The game ended. The field flooded with celebrating BYU fans.
In the space of a few hours, both the No. 1 and No. 2 teams in the country had vanished int the Thanos dust cloud
The chaos was gathering momentum.
Tennessee 26, No. 6 Alabama 10

Neyland Stadium smells blood
Some upsets happen because a favourite makes mistakes. This was not one of those.
Tennessee simply bullied Alabama.
The Volunteers forced four turnovers, limited Alabama to just 201 total yards, controlled the line of scrimmage and never allowed the Tide to establish any sustained offensive rhythm.
The final score actually flatters Alabama. Anyone who watched could see Tennessee had been the better side for most of the afternoon.
For a programme accustomed to discussing playoffs rather than problems, Alabama suddenly finds itself facing difficult questions and very little margin for error.
Florida at Texas 27-24
Is the Arch Manning era arriving too early?
A month ago, Texas looked like a programme building towards a playoff run.
Now they’re becoming one of the biggest storylines in the sport for entirely the wrong reasons.
An unranked Florida team walked into Austin and handed the Longhorns a second consecutive defeat, leaving Texas with far more questions than answers.
Most of those questions begin with Arch Manning.
That might be unfair. It is also…inevitable.
When you carry the Manning surname, fairness left the building years ago.
Every throw becomes a headline. Every incompletion becomes a debate. Every defeat becomes an investigation.
Against Florida, Manning struggled to consistently move the offence and never looked fully comfortable against a defence that arrived with significantly less hype than the quarterback lining up opposite them.
The issue, however, extends beyond the quarterback.
Increasingly, attention is turning towards Steve Sarkisian.
For several seasons, Sarkisian has been praised as one of the sport’s premier offensive minds. When Texas are rolling, his scheme looks like a masterclass. When they’re struggling, critics argue it sometimes looks overly complicated, particularly when a young quarterback is being asked to carry the weight of enormous expectations.
Following a second straight defeat, that debate has intensified.
Is Manning being asked to do too much? Has Sarkisian become too reliant on the former five-star quarterback? Is Texas still a legitimate championship contender, or was the programme’s rapid ascent slightly overstated?
Those conversations would have seemed ridiculous a couple of weeks ago.
After this defeat, they’re unavoidable.
The most concerning thing for Longhorn supporters isn’t that they’ve lost twice. It’s that confidence appears to be evaporating.
The first loss felt like a bad afternoon. The second felt like the beginning of a trend.
And in college football, once people start asking whether you’ve got a quarterback problem, a coaching problem or a confidence problem, it rarely matters which one is actually true, because the fact is, Texas, you have a problem
No. 4 Ohio State 19, No. 5 Indiana 15

Survival is a skill. Now comes the hard part.
Technically, this wasn’t an upset. It was still one of the defining games of the weekend.
While almost every other contender was busy sabotaging itself, Ohio State travelled to Bloomington and escaped with a gritty 19-15 victory over Indiana. The defeat ended Indiana’s remarkable 22-game winning streak.
The Buckeyes weren’t spectacular. They didn’t need to be, Week 7 was all about staying alive.
Ohio State managed it, but at what cost?
With star QB Julian Sayin leaving the game in the 4th Quarter and being seen on the sideline in a sling to close the game out, what Ohio State fans hoped was just a temporary measure has been confirmed by Coach Day. Sayin is out indefinitely.
This win would have put them in the top 5…but without their QB are they now out of playoff contention (as a Seminole fan, that’s how it works right.. RIGHT?)
The Steve Young Victory Lap
Every chaos weekend needs somebody who saw it coming.
This week it felt like that person was BYU Royalty, HoF Legend Steve Young.
While much of the college football media spent the week discussing rankings, résumés and playoff positioning, Young appeared far more willing to entertain the possibility that momentum matters, and that October football is just ingerrently unstable
As favourite after favourite stumbled, his willingness to deviate from conventional wisdom looked increasingly impressive. Young seem to remember that this sport in particular, rungs on Emotions, momentum, hostile home field advantages and importantly. 20 year olds making decisions whilst 100,000 fans scream at them from the bleachers.
By the end of Saturday, several analysts were probably revisiting their prediction sheets with the sort of regret usually reserved for missed lottery numbers.
Whether it was insight, instinct or simple football intuition, Young emerged from what I’m dubbing ‘Thanos Weekend’ looking like College Football’s Dr Strange – he’d seen the 14 million permutations, and somehow amongst the chaos, picked the right one – 10 TIMES!!
The Seminoles Segment

The officials may need witness protection
Florida State lost 43-35 to unbeaten rival Miami after two overtimes. Yet somehow the scoreboard was only the second-biggest story.
The Seminoles produced arguably their most spirited performance of the season.
Late in regulation, quarterback Ashton Daniels found Duce Robinson on a 75-yard touchdown strike that tied the game and sent the rivalry into overtime.
Then the madness truly began
Trailing by a score late in second overtime, the Noles appeared to keep their hopes alive with a miraculous fourth-and-21 touchdown conversion. Celebrations erupted. Hope returned. Then the zebras intervened and the score was erased because of a ‘holding’ penalty.
The Seminoles still had one final chance.
Facing fourth-and-31, Daniels launched a desperate Hail Mary into the darkness. Players collided. Bodies fell everywhere. Miami ’emerged’ with possession. The play was reviewed. The call stood. Game over.
Depending on your allegiance, the officials either correctly applied the rules under immense pressure or committed an act that will be discussed by Florida State fans until approximately 2043.
The Seminoles lost, but for the first time in a while, they left the field looking like a team rather than a cautionary tale.
Progress comes in many forms.
The Real Winner
College football. It’s Always college football.
No. 1 lost. No. 2 lost. No. 6 lost. No. 7 lost.
No. 5 lost to No. 4 in a top-five heavyweight fight. No. 4 lost their QB
Five of the top seven teams in the country were beaten on the same day, something that had never happened before in the AP Poll era!
By next Saturday we’ll convince ourselves that the rankings make sense again. We’ll identify the new contenders, write fresh playoff projections and confidently explain exactly how the season will unfold.
Week 7 served as an important reminder that college football has absolutely no interest in our plans.
And that’s precisely why we love it.
If you’d like to hear more of Gary’s opinions on college football, or any of our other opinions on football, check out the AAW podcasts. Join us on Saturday’s and Sunday’s in using The Hub.



